Why You Should Choose A Independent Insurance Agent
March 23, 2023
Business meeting around a conference table, with laptops and notes as one person speaks to the group.

What Is an Independent Insurance Agent?

By Josh Miner, Owner of Miner Family Insurance, an independent insurance agency in Edmond, OK

An independent insurance agent is a licensed agent who represents many insurance companies instead of just one. That lets the agent compare coverage and prices across carriers and recommend the best fit for you. Independent agents are paid by the carrier you choose, so most, including Miner Family Insurance, charge clients no fees.

I started Miner Family Insurance in 2020 to make insurance simpler and give Oklahoma families real options. Here is how independent agents work and why the model benefits you.

How Does an Independent Insurance Agent Work?

An independent agent holds appointments with multiple insurance companies. When you need coverage, the agent gathers your information once, then quotes several carriers. You see the options side by side and choose the one that fits. The agent then services the policy, helps with changes, and supports you at claim time.

At Miner Family Insurance, we work with 50+ carriers across personal, commercial, and life insurance. That means one call can get you many quotes.

What Are the Benefits of an Independent Insurance Agent?

The benefits of an independent insurance agent come down to choice, advice, and service. Here is what that looks like in practice:

  • More options: quotes from many carriers, not just one
  • Unbiased advice: the agent works for you, not a single company
  • Better coverage fit: policies matched to your home, car, and budget
  • Re-shopping: when rates jump, the agent can move you to a better carrier
  • One point of contact: home, auto, life, and business in one place
  • Claims support: a real person helps you through the process
  • Local knowledge: an agent who knows Oklahoma weather and risks

How Is an Independent Agent Different From a Captive Agent?

A captive agent works for one insurance company and can only sell that company's policies. An independent agent can sell policies from many companies. Both can be helpful, but only an independent agent can compare prices and coverage across the market.

Feature

Independent Agent

Captive Agent

Buying Direct Online

Number of carriers

Many

One

One per site

Personal advice

Yes

Yes

Limited

Re-shops at renewal

Yes

No

No

Claims help

Yes

Varies

Call center

Fees at Miner Family Insurance

None

Usually none

None

How Do Independent Agents Get Paid?

Independent agents earn a commission from the insurance company that writes your policy. That commission is already built into the premium. You pay the same price whether you buy through an independent agent or directly from that carrier. At Miner Family Insurance, we charge no fees on top of your premium.

What Types of Insurance Can an Independent Agent Help With?

Most independent agents handle personal and business insurance. At Miner Family Insurance, that includes:

  • Home, condo, renters, and landlord insurance
  • Auto, motorcycle, boat, and RV insurance
  • Umbrella and high-value home coverage
  • Life insurance
  • Commercial insurance for small and mid-size businesses
  • Apartment and habitational coverage for investors

We do not sell health insurance, but we can point you in the right direction.

Is an Independent Agent Always Cheaper?

Not always, but you get the best chance at the right price. An independent agent can show you several prices for the same coverage, so you can see where the market really is. Sometimes the win is not the lowest price. It is better coverage, a lower deductible, or a carrier with a stronger claims reputation for the same money.

Why Does an Independent Agent Matter More in Oklahoma?

Oklahoma's weather makes insurance more complicated. Hail, wind, and tornadoes drive frequent rate changes and new rules on roofs and deductibles. When one carrier raises rates or tightens coverage, an independent agent can move you to another company without starting from scratch. A captive agent cannot.

What Should You Look for in an Independent Agent?

Look for experience, access, and service. Ask how many carriers the agency represents for the type of insurance you need. Read their Google reviews. Ask whether they re-shop at renewal and how they help with claims. Make sure they are licensed in Oklahoma and easy to reach when you need them.

Why Choose Miner Family Insurance?

Choose us because we built the agency around options and service. We are Edmond's highest rated independent agency on Google, with a 5.0 rating and 320+ reviews. We were voted Best Insurance Agency in the 405 by 405 Magazine in 2023. We re-shop policies at renewal, help with every claim, and never charge fees.

Independent Insurance Agent FAQs

What is an independent insurance agent in simple terms?

It is an agent who can sell policies from many insurance companies, so they can shop for the best fit for you.

Do independent insurance agents charge a fee?

Most do not. They are paid a commission by the carrier. Miner Family Insurance charges no fees.

Is it better to use an independent agent or a captive agent?

For most people, an independent agent gives more choice, since a captive agent can only quote one company.

Can an independent agent help with claims?

Yes. A good independent agent helps you file, explains your coverage, and follows up with the carrier.

Can I keep the same agent if I switch insurance companies?

Yes. That is a key benefit. Your independent agent can move you between carriers while you keep the same local contact.

Talk to an Independent Insurance Agent

Call Miner Family Insurance at (405) 724-2389 or request a quote online. One call gets you quotes from our network of carriers, with no fees and real local service.

Suburban house with landscaped yard, white garage, and red fence under a clear blue sky
By Joshua Miner • October 27, 2026
Oklahoma home insurance averages $4,700 to $7,700 a year in 2026, double the U.S. An Edmond agent explains why and shares real local rates by city.
Aerial view of an Edmond-area neighborhood where home insurance rates vary
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Why is my home insurance so high? Learn why Edmond neighbors pay different rates, from roofs and credit to discounts, and how to lower your premium.
Home insurance graphic with hands supporting a small house and text about guest injuries at home
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Does homeowners insurance cover guest injuries? An Edmond agent explains premises liability, what to do after a guest is hurt, and umbrella coverage.
Large brick-and-siding suburban house with a front porch, dormer windows, and a green lawn under a blue sky
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Choosing Edmond home insurance? A local agent explains rebuild cost, extended replacement cost coverage, liability limits, deductibles, and more.
Snow-covered log cabins and evergreen trees in a winter village scene
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Ice storm, fallen tree, or frozen pipes? An Edmond agent explains what Oklahoma homeowners insurance covers in winter and how loss of use works.
Home insurance graphic with house in hands and text: “What to Do If Your Home Is Damaged in a Natural Disaster”
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Tornado, hail, or flood damage? An Edmond agent explains how to file a homeowners insurance claim in Oklahoma and what your policy covers.
Woman working on a laptop at her kitchen table, running a business from home
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Running a business from your Edmond home? Learn what home insurance covers, what it doesn't, and your options for home based business insurance.
Red umbrella in the rain, a symbol of umbrella liability insurance
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Learn how homeowners liability coverage protects Oklahoma families, how much personal liability coverage you need, and when umbrella insurance makes sense.
Two-story brick home protected by extended replacement cost coverage
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
What is extended replacement cost coverage? Learn how it protects Oklahoma homes when rebuild costs rise, how it differs from guaranteed replacement cost.
Woman holding house keys beside a red model house on a table, with a laptop in the background
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Home safety tips from an Edmond, OK agent: prevent house fires, frozen pipes, water damage, and break-ins to avoid homeowners insurance claims.
Show More