Homeowners vs Renters Insurance vs Landlord Insurance
Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026



Homeowners vs Renters Insurance vs Landlord Insurance



By Josh Miner, a licensed agent and the founder of Miner Family Insurance in Edmond, OK. Updated October 2026.


Homeowners, renters, and landlord insurance sound alike, but they protect very different things. Picking the wrong one can leave a big gap, especially if you move out and rent your old house.


Here's how each policy works, who needs it, and how to choose the right one in Edmond and the OKC metro.



How Do These Policies Compare?




  • Homeowners insurance: For people who own and live in their home. Covers the building, your belongings, and your liability.
  • Renters insurance: For tenants. Covers your belongings and your liability, but not the building.
  • Landlord insurance: For owners who rent a home to someone else. Covers the building, lost rent, and your liability as the owner.




What Does Homeowners Insurance Cover?



Two-story family home with a front lawn covered by homeowners insurance


A standard homeowners policy covers the home you own and live in. It usually includes:



  • Dwelling: The house itself, including the roof, walls, and built-in systems
  • Other structures: Fences, sheds, and detached garages
  • Personal property: Furniture, clothes, electronics, and other belongings
  • Loss of use: Extra living costs if a covered loss forces you out of your home
  • Personal liability: Injuries or damage you're legally responsible for



Edmond homeowners insurance also has to handle Oklahoma's wind and hail. Check your roof coverage and your wind and hail deductible.



What Does Renters Insurance Cover?



Apartment living room with belongings covered by renters insurance


Renters insurance protects you, not the building. Your landlord's policy covers the structure, but it won't pay for your things.



  • Personal property: Your belongings, at home or on the go
  • Personal liability: If a guest is hurt or you damage the building by mistake
  • Loss of use: Hotel and meal costs if your apartment becomes unlivable after a covered loss



Edmond renters insurance is usually one of the cheapest policies you can buy. Many landlords also require it in the lease.



What Does Landlord Insurance Cover?



House for rent sign in front of a rental home covered by landlord insurance


Landlord insurance is for a home you own but rent to someone else. It's often called a dwelling policy. It usually covers:



  • The building: Repairs after covered damage like wind, hail, or fire
  • Other structures: Fences, sheds, and detached garages on the property
  • Loss of rental income: Lost rent while the home is being repaired after a covered loss
  • Liability: Injuries on the property that you're responsible for as the owner (often included or added on)



It doesn't cover your tenant's belongings. They need their own renters policy.



How Landlord Insurance Loss of Rental Income Works


Say a hailstorm damages the roof of your rental, and your tenant has to move out for two months during repairs. Landlord insurance loss of rental income coverage can replace the rent you would have collected. Some policies call it fair rental value. Homeowners policies don't include this.



Landlord vs Homeowners Insurance: What's the Difference?



The biggest difference is who lives in the home. Homeowners insurance assumes you live there. Landlord insurance assumes a tenant does.



  • Belongings: Homeowners covers your stuff. Landlord insurance usually only covers items you keep there for the rental, like appliances.
  • Lost rent: Landlord insurance can pay it. Homeowners doesn't.
  • Loss of use: Homeowners pays your hotel bills. Landlord insurance pays lost rent instead.
  • Liability: Both can include it, but landlord liability is built around owning a rental.



If you move out and rent your old house, call your agent before the tenant moves in. A homeowners policy may not cover a home you don't live in.



Homeowners vs Renters Insurance: What's the Difference?



Homeowners insurance covers the building and what's inside. Renters insurance only covers what's inside, plus your liability.


That's why renters insurance costs much less. With renters insurance, you aren't paying to rebuild a house. Both policies include personal liability and loss of use.



Which Policy Do You Need?




  • You own and live in your home: Homeowners insurance
  • You rent an apartment or house: Renters insurance
  • You own a home and rent it out: Landlord insurance
  • You own a condo: Condo insurance, which covers the inside of your unit
  • You rent out a room or short-term rental: Talk to your agent, since many policies limit this




What About Condo Insurance?



Condo building with balconies


Condo owners need their own type of policy. Your HOA has a master policy, and it usually covers the outside of the building and shared spaces. Condo insurance covers the inside of your unit, like floors, cabinets, and fixtures, plus your belongings and liability.


Read your HOA bylaws to see where the master policy stops. That tells you how much coverage you need for the inside of your unit.



How Much Coverage Do You Need?




  • Homeowners: Insure your home for what it would cost to rebuild, not what you paid or what it would sell for.
  • Renters: Add up what it would cost to replace your belongings. Most people are surprised by the total.
  • Landlords: Cover the rebuild cost of the rental, plus several months of rent in case of a long repair.
  • Everyone: Carry enough liability to protect your savings. Many families choose at least $300,000.




What Mistakes Should You Avoid?




  • Keeping a homeowners policy on a rental. If you move out and rent your home, your old policy may not respond to a claim.
  • Assuming the landlord covers your things. Their policy covers the building, not your furniture or electronics.
  • Skipping liability as a landlord. Tenants and their guests can be hurt on your property.
  • Forgetting to tell your agent about changes. Moving, renting out a room, or starting a short-term rental can all affect your coverage.




What Should Edmond Landlord Insurance Cover?



Edmond has a busy rental market. Many renters are families and students near UCO. If you own a rental, keep these tips in mind:



  • Require tenants to carry renters insurance in your lease.
  • Check your wind and hail deductible, since roof claims are common in Oklahoma.
  • Make sure your loss of rental income limit covers several months of rent.
  • Consider an umbrella policy if you own more than one rental.




Frequently Asked Questions




Can I use homeowners insurance on a rental property?


Usually not. Once you move out and rent the home, you typically need a landlord policy instead.



Does my landlord's insurance cover my belongings?


No. Your landlord's policy covers the building. You need renters insurance for your things.



Is renters insurance worth it?


In most cases, yes. It's affordable and covers your belongings and liability.



What is loss of rental income coverage?


It pays the rent you lose while your rental is repaired after a covered loss, like a fire or storm.



Do condo owners need their own policy?


Yes. Your HOA policy covers the building, but you need condo insurance for the inside of your unit and your belongings.



Talk to an Edmond Insurance Agent



We're Miner Family Insurance, a local, independent agency right here in Edmond. We compare homeowners, renters, and landlord insurance from more than 50 carriers, and we never charge fees. Call 405-724-2389 or request a home, renters, or landlord insurance quote online.


Suburban house with landscaped yard, white garage, and red fence under a clear blue sky
By Joshua Miner • October 27, 2026
Oklahoma home insurance averages $4,700 to $7,700 a year in 2026, double the U.S. An Edmond agent explains why and shares real local rates by city.
Aerial view of an Edmond-area neighborhood where home insurance rates vary
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Why is my home insurance so high? Learn why Edmond neighbors pay different rates, from roofs and credit to discounts, and how to lower your premium.
Home insurance graphic with hands supporting a small house and text about guest injuries at home
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Does homeowners insurance cover guest injuries? An Edmond agent explains premises liability, what to do after a guest is hurt, and umbrella coverage.
Large brick-and-siding suburban house with a front porch, dormer windows, and a green lawn under a blue sky
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Choosing Edmond home insurance? A local agent explains rebuild cost, extended replacement cost coverage, liability limits, deductibles, and more.
Snow-covered log cabins and evergreen trees in a winter village scene
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Ice storm, fallen tree, or frozen pipes? An Edmond agent explains what Oklahoma homeowners insurance covers in winter and how loss of use works.
Home insurance graphic with house in hands and text: “What to Do If Your Home Is Damaged in a Natural Disaster”
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Tornado, hail, or flood damage? An Edmond agent explains how to file a homeowners insurance claim in Oklahoma and what your policy covers.
Woman working on a laptop at her kitchen table, running a business from home
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Running a business from your Edmond home? Learn what home insurance covers, what it doesn't, and your options for home based business insurance.
Red umbrella in the rain, a symbol of umbrella liability insurance
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Learn how homeowners liability coverage protects Oklahoma families, how much personal liability coverage you need, and when umbrella insurance makes sense.
Two-story brick home protected by extended replacement cost coverage
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
What is extended replacement cost coverage? Learn how it protects Oklahoma homes when rebuild costs rise, how it differs from guaranteed replacement cost.
Woman holding house keys beside a red model house on a table, with a laptop in the background
By Joshua Miner • October 23, 2026
Home safety tips from an Edmond, OK agent: prevent house fires, frozen pipes, water damage, and break-ins to avoid homeowners insurance claims.
Show More